Presumed Innocence, Proof, & Pain

Because the law rightly upholds the principle that a man is innocent until proved guilty, it can unintentionally create an uneven playing field for women who come forward with allegations of sexual abuse.

The burden of proof often falls heavily upon them, forcing survivors to relive their trauma in an atmosphere of doubt and scrutiny. When their words are met with suspicion rather than compassion, it reinforces the deep sense of violation they’ve already endured. The fear of not being believed can silence many women altogether, leaving abuse unchallenged and perpetrators unaccountable.

For those who do speak out, disbelief can wound as deeply as the original assault, eroding trust in justice, in community, and even in themselves. In this way, a principle designed to protect fairness can, without sensitivity and balance, deepen injustice for those whose voices most need to be heard.

Only through sensitivity, compassion, and a willingness to truly listen can we begin to create a culture where justice is balanced with understanding, and survivors are met not with doubt, but with dignity.

Leave a comment