After Jesus’ Ascension, the disciples faced the task of replacing Judas Iscariot. In Acts 1:15–17, 21–26, they chose two men, Joseph called Barsabbas and Matthias, then prayed and cast lots, and the lot fell to Matthias. He was added to the eleven apostles, but interestingly, this is the last time Scripture mentions him. There’s no record of his ministry or influence in the early church.

This raises the question: was choosing Matthias truly God’s will, or a well-intended human decision? While casting lots was an accepted practice at the time for discerning God’s will, perhaps this was an instance of acting too soon, of moving ahead of God’s timing. The apostles prayed, yes, but they also acted before the Holy Spirit had come at Pentecost. Did they mistake activity for obedience?

As the story unfolds in Acts, it becomes clear that God had someone else in mind, Saul of Tarsus. A fierce persecutor of Christians, Saul was completely outside the disciples’ consideration. Yet in Acts 9:1–19, God stops him on the road to Damascus, blinds him, transforms him, and sets him on a path to become Paul, the apostle to the Gentiles.

Paul became the dominant voice in the early church. His letters make up a significant portion of the New Testament. The Life Application Bible even notes that no one, apart from Jesus, shaped Christianity more than Paul. His passion, once used against the church, was redirected for the gospel. Clearly, God’s plan was far greater than what the disciples could have imagined.

This story highlights how easy it is to make ‘Matthias-type’ decisions, rushed, reactive choices that may seem spiritual but aren’t fully surrendered to God’s timing or Spirit. How often do we make decisions out of pressure, impatience, or a need to check a box, then ask God to bless what we’ve already chosen?

Yet God’s timing is perfect. Sometimes the best thing we can do is wait, pray, and live in the tension of not knowing. God often works in the unlikely, the unseen, and the slow. He chose Paul when no one else would have, reminding us that his plans surpass human logic.

Still, we shouldn’t assume Matthias had no purpose. Just because Scripture doesn’t record his story doesn’t mean God didn’t use him. Many faithful servants throughout history have gone unnamed, but they’ve played vital roles in God’s kingdom. Not everyone is called to be a Paul, but all are called to be faithful.

Whether we feel like a Matthias or a Paul, the invitation is the same: to seek God’s will, to wait when needed, and to trust that he has a purpose for each of us. Even when our role seems small or hidden, God sees it, and uses it, for his glory.